Emissions based parking can help cut car use on the road to net zero

Introducing clean air zones would undeniably cut emissions from transport, but such schemes are costly, take time and face high levels of public scrutiny. There is a quicker, simpler and cheaper option - emissions based parking, writes Anne Snelson

11 June 2023

UK greenhouse gas emissions national statistics 2022 from the Dept for Business, Energy & Industrial Strategy, published 30 March 2023 (https://tinyurl.com/58a84abr)

An active travel expert recently took me to task for avoiding the ‘Elephant in the Room’ after I posted a piece on what town and city managers could do to increase sustainability.

The elephant in question is transport. So, I thought it only right to acknowledge the elephant, and offer what I think are practical and affordable measures that could be implemented without delay.

What’s the issue?

The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) states that emission growth must halt by 2025 and halve by 2030¹ if we’re to keep within the critical 1.5°C global threshold. That’s quite a challenge for transport as we’re the UK’s largest emitting sector² and emissions, post-Covid, are currently on the rise.

Achieving net zero

To stay on track with achieving net zero, Transport for Quality of Life³ and the Green Alliance⁴ say we must cut UK car mileage by 20% - 27% by 2030. Scotland has already committed to the lower end of this: reducing road traffic by 20%⁵.

So, how can we achieve this? Numerous solutions exist.

Clean air, low and ultra low emission zones are an obvious answer in urban areas but are costly, take time and are subject to high levels of public scrutiny and pressure.

An easier option is emissions based parking (EBP), which varies parking charges based on the emissions of the vehicle being parked. With no physical gantries or cameras, it’s also significantly cheaper.

First used in Richmond upon Thames in 2009, mainstream usage started in 2017, when Westminster City Council started trialling EBP. Overnight, the council saw parked vehicles drop by 16%, with little sign of increases elsewhere⁶. The council estimated that with full roll-out across Westminster, 250,000 journeys would be cut each year.

Islington Council, Camden Council and City of London Corporation quickly followed suit. In each case reducing parking by 13% - 20%, with no adverse impact on the bottom line. Other councils have joined, with Hackney⁷ and Lambeth⁸ the latest, in April and May this year.

Communicate the rationale

Pricing and communication are critical to success. For behaviour change to happen, price increases must be significant and perceived as fair. A positive rationale is also key to the schemes gaining acceptance.

Hackney Council announced its decision to move to variable pricing as part of its five-year strategy, focusing on residents’ health and more sustainable streets⁹. The council carried out a 13-week consultation and three-week in-depth listening exercise, in which over 9,000 people provided their views.

Pushing up tariffs

While EBP is undoubtedly effective, over time, traffic starts to rise. So further price increases can be required. Islington Council has increased its differential multiple times. With hourly rates for diesels on a par with the daily ULEZ charge, it’s perhaps unsurprising that PM2.5 emissions in central London have dropped by 29%¹⁰.

Some argue against EBP, calling it socially divisive: penalising those within society who are least able to afford it. However, it’s these lower income residents, who without EBP, are subject to harmful air.

Public Health England states that 28,000 - 36,000 deaths a year are caused by long term exposure to poor air quality¹¹, so why should these people be put at risk? Not least when two-thirds of Islington residents do not own a car¹².

Highlighting the benefits

Numerous other opportunities exist to cut traffic, reduce emissions and promote change. Measures that have cut driving and encouraged modal shift include: school streets; low traffic and 15-minute neighbourhoods; park & ride; low speed and restricted zones. Simply raising parking charges has a similar effect.

Proposing such schemes can be controversial, but the benefits for all of us cannot be denied. Communicating such changes positively is therefore key to success.

Hackney Council’s consultation process provided strong evidence on which to base its change. Justification can be strengthened with holistic thinking, ring-fencing and reinvesting funds in public transport or encouraging active travel use.

Last chance saloon

The threat of climate change has been known for more than four decades and we’re now at the point of no return¹³. We have the tools and solutions to avoid irreversible change. The question we as an industry must answer though is, will we use them?

Anne Snelson is founder of Lead with Sustainability, a consultancy helping individuals and organisations reduce their planetary impact.

1 https://www.ipcc.ch/2022/04/04/ipcc-ar6-wgiii-pressrelease/

2 https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/1134663/emissions-statistics-summary-2021.pdf

3 http://www.transportforqualityoflife.com/u/files/211214%20The%20last%20chance%20saloon%20to%20cut%20car%20mileage.pdf

4 https://green-alliance.org.uk/publication/moving-on-greener-travel-for-the-uk/

5 https://www.transport.gov.scot/publication/a-route-map-to-achieve-a-20-per-cent-reduction-in-car-kilometres-by-2030/

6 https://www.openaccessgovernment.org/going-digital-how-can-organisations-reduce-carbon-emissions/143545/

7 https://ringgo.co.uk/hackney-council-uses-ringgo-parking-to-influence-emissions/

8 https://www.lambeth.gov.uk/parking/emission-based-parking-charges

9 https://consultation.hackney.gov.uk/parking-markets/pep2021-26/supporting_documents/HDS14176%20Parking%20and%20enforcement%20plan%20strategy%20A4%20v3.pdf

10 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-62224609

11 https://www.gov.uk/government/news/public-health-england-publishes-air-pollution-evidence-review